Scandal hits BC gov’t gambling site on first day of operation

Calvin Ayre
Calvin Ayre
July 22, 2010
21 Comments

BCLC-PlayNow-OversightWhat is there left to say about the BC Lottery Corp.’s launch (and subsequent crash just hours later) of its expanded online gaming site, PlayNow.com? What jokes are left to wring out of this farce? (PrayNow, PlayLater, etc.) At what point does the situation cease being funny? For many, that moment arrived with the news that PlayNow users’ data had been unnecessarily exposed during the snafu. So I guess you can add PlayAtYourOwnRisk to the list of punchlines.

As BCLC officials muddle through their self-described ‘week from hell’, it’s hard not to think of the parallels between what BCLC is going through and the environmental clusterfuck currently playing out in the Gulf of Mexico. That may sound like a stretch, but think about it in terms of how the executives from both companies dealt with their respective crises.

As late as a month after the original incident that caused the oil to leak, BP officials were stating that the environmental impact on the Gulf would be “very, very modest.” BP also seriously low-balled the estimated number of barrels of oil spewing from the well each day. Then CEO/Rodeo Clown Tony Hayward categorically stated “there are no [oil] plumes” floating below the surface, until multiple groups of scientists produced video footage of said plumes. Like the man said, who are you going to believe, me or your own eyes?

The day after PlayNow crashed, a BCLC press release said that the site was voluntarily taken offline because of concerns over an overabundance of players leading to ‘slowness’ and ‘not good responsiveness’. This turned out to be something of a ‘not good response’ and BCLC eventually coughed up the (partial) truth three days later, although we still don’t know whether the exposure of players’ financial info was a case of technical incompetence or shoddy defense measures leaving the system vulnerable to malicious hacking. Despite their obvious attempt at obfuscation, BCLC officials claim they “haven’t lied to anyone.” They must be operating under the George Costanza principle that “it’s not a lie if you believe it.”

What both of these situations have in common is a shocking lack of oversight. In BP’s case, it was the U.S. government’s toothless and disinterested Mineral Management Service, who largely took BP at its word that it was doing all it could to prevent such a catastrophic event from occurring, and hey, even if it did, they were capable of dealing with an event ten times the size of the current spill. Sure, they were.

In BCLC’s case, being a branch of government, they were literally in charge of verifying their own diligence (or lack thereof), which is a bit like having an Olympic figure skater grade themselves after a performance and then using that score as the barometer for handing out the hardware. ‘Another gold medal? Aww, you shouldn’t have… Toss it on the pile with the others, will ya?’

It never ceases to amaze me that a government like the one in BC loves to demonize privately-held, internationally-operated gambling companies, while simultaneously holding themselves up as pillars of propriety. Yet it’s the privately-held companies that voluntarily submit to rigorous inspection by internationally-recognized licensing bodies, while BC’s government simply says ‘trust us’. Even though this particular BC government has a distinctly dodgy track record when it comes to the issue of trust (and if you don’t trust me on this, check here, here or here). And that’s not even addressing the issue of the ‘irregularities’ on BCLC’s land-based casino ledgers.

The truth is that BC wasn’t adequately prepared to launch their expanded online gambling product, and now they’re paying the consequences. What’s particularly galling is that if they’d just bothered to consult with some homegrown industry experts before charging out the gate, this whole debacle could have been avoided. Before I changed my business model to a brand-licensing operation, Bodog ran a number of technology companies out of Vancouver. With over a decade’s worth of experience, these companies could have provided invaluable assistance to the development of BC’s online gambling plans, but the BC gov’t couldn’t be arsed. In fact, BC did much to discourage these companies from operating in this space, so much so that when BC decided to get into the business for themselves, they were forced to look overseas for technical help. And just look where that got them. They’re the laughing stock of the industry and getting some serious blowback in the mainstream press. They sowed the wind, and now they’ve reaped the whirlwind. And it was all so unnecessary.

If you have any further information related to this story that you would like to share with us privately please click here.

Can't get enough CalvinAyre.com? Follow us on Twitter and Facebook, then you'll never miss out on the latest gaming industry news.

Share
Tags: Article, BCLC, playnow.com
Views and opinions expressed are those of the Author and do not necessarily reflect those of CalvinAyre.com
  • http://topsy.com/calvinayre.com/2010/07/22/business/scandal-hits-bc-gambling-site-on-first-day/?utm_source=pingback&utm_campaign=L2 Tweets that mention Scandal hits BC gov’t gambling site on first day of operation — Topsy.com

    [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Adrian Eden, BiLL Beatty and Danjal Es, ermando brown. ermando brown said: Scandal hits BC gov't gambling site on first day of operation: Calvin Ayre takes BC Lottery Corp. to the woodshed … http://bit.ly/c9KEb3 [...]

  • BC Boy

    Yeah, it was pretty embarrassing for them to have this happen amongst the other things that you noted. I guess politicians will never have any honor. They could have used any third party hosting provider and received better results. If you look at any Canadian Gov't website you will see signs of the 90's, I wonder why they are so behind the times in Technology? Weird.

  • RyanG

    It's nice to see the perspective of an industry veteran commenting on this. Obviously you have a lot of experience in this area. Thanks for the thought provoking article.

  • http://calvinayre.com/2010/07/23/business/french-gamblers-shun-state-betting-sites/ Half of French gamblers shun state-sanctioned betting sites

    [...] ago, we like to think this distrust of state-sanctioned wagering will eventually become known as the PlayNow effect. (FYI, in French, that would be l’effet du jeu maintenant.) Read more.Views and opinions [...]

  • Jaysonmore4

    As usual, the greedy gov't screws up what the private sector should be operating. Well said and thanks for the info!

  • http://calvinayre.com/2010/07/23/business/calvin-ayre-slams-bclc-play-now-on-cbc/ Calvin Ayre tells CBC that BCLC blew it with PlayNow launch

    [...] Brand founder Calvin Ayre appeared on CBC’s nightly newscast on Thursday to continue his rebuke of BCLC for the bungled launch of their online gambling site, PlayNow.com. While BC premier Gordon Campbell [...]

  • http://calvinayre.com/2010/07/28/business/bclc-playnow-offline-until-privacy-addressed/ BCLC PlayNow site staying offline until privacy concerns addressed

    [...] Minister of No Shit Sherlock, sorry, Information and Privacy Commissioner, has declared that the troubled PlayNow online gambling site will remain offline until those foreign technology ‘gurus’ bring the website’s back end [...]

  • http://calvinayre.com/2010/08/05/legal/canada-classifies-poker-as-serious-crime/ Did Canada just classify playing poker as a ‘serious crime?’

    [...] Hey, Tories… If you really want to look tough on crime, why not arrest those criminally inept PlayNow doofuses? Read more.Views and opinions expressed are those of the Author and do not necessarily [...]

  • http://calvinayre.com/2010/08/11/business/calvin-ayre-cbc-the-national-ontario-lotteries-corporation/ Calvin Ayre tells CBC’s The National he hopes Ontario’s online gambling site doesn’t suck

    [...] And Gaming Corporation works out the kinks BEFORE the site starts handling players’ money (unlike BCLC and their now notorious PlayNow). Seriously, get good technology – preferably Made In Canada technology. Because you know the [...]

  • http://calvinayre.com/2010/08/12/legal/alberta-waits-for-ontario/ Alberta waits patiently for Ontario

    [...] 2010 View commentsCommentsCanada really is a country of wildly differing extremes. First off we had British Columbia trying to fool us into thinking they knew what they were doing by springing a site on us. Now we’ve got Ontario, [...]

  • http://calvinayre.com/2010/08/20/business/self-regulated-bclc-regulators-say-wonky-playnow-all-better-now/ Self-regulated BCLC regulators say wonky PlayNow all better now

    [...] PlayNow all better now Steven Stradbrooke August 20, 2010 View CommentsMore than a month after its spectacular flameout just after liftoff, British Columbia’s online gaming site PlayNow is back in business. (Just how long it will stay [...]

  • http://calvinayre.com/2010/08/29/business/calvin-ayre-home-province-loves-to-gamble/ The province of my birth loves to gamble… Coincidence or fate?

    [...] footsteps so closely that they trip over their own feet and perform a spectacular faceplant à la PlayNow.com.In fact, if Saskatchewan was serious about going down this road, I’d be honored if they asked me, [...]

  • http://calvinayre.com/2010/08/30/business/bclc-playnow-free-money-bonus-offer/ BCLC PlayNow.com ‘free money’ bonus offer won’t last long, so cash in now

    [...] aren’t fools.We can’t say with absolute certainty that PlayNow are a bunch of fools, even if their previous exploits suggest they’re serious Three Stooges fans. It is entirely plausible that Playnow intended to [...]

  • KJ

    I am always perplexed why some outspoken individual’s posts never seem to get many good responses or follow up posts and I am wondering if people (in general) are scared to reply or simply feel there is nothing worth replying to. I am hoping the latter…

    For example, Calvin’s comments on BCLC’s PlayNow site launch and its issues. Let’s start by saying (assuming), Calvin has never had any issues or done any wrong with his Bodog brand but I can’t say either way but wonder why he left town ; )

    Playnow screwed up (I agree) but he seems to think he is the saviour and has all the answers and that they should have consulted him (prior to launching) so his exemplary expertise could have solved all of their problems beforehand. But heck, he did like their Playnow site but credits its design to most of his old employees and that’s why it’s good! Hmmm, let me get this straight, Calvin (Bodog) educated (not BCIT, SFU, UBC or other local colleges, etc) and trained these ex employees that it later let go. In his eyes there is no way they could not have come up with this design without having worked for him first. Newsflash; I have designed many sites and although the site is easy to look at and friendly, it is by no means ground breaking or awesome, it is simply a site which looks like many others! But thank you CA for training the minion’s who designed it!

    So if it is done right, thanks to CA but if not, they are idiots who resembled a catastrophic oil disaster which on the world scale is in the BILLIONS of dollars and caused loss of industry, life and the collapse of companies. Hmmmmm why don’t people compare Apples to Apples anymore? ; ) The Oil Disaster has very little that it can compare to!

    A post is just that, a post of one’s opinions and you should feel free to reply and reply WITH YOUR opinion. Who knows, it may be correct or at least, more informative of the facts!

    Gamble, drink well and carry on, as it goes!
    KJ

  • http://calvinayre.com/2011/01/24/business/virgin-gaming-mixes-video-games-social-media-betting/ Virgin Gaming’s game-changing mix of video games, social media and betting

    [...] approves of is the government-operated variety — even when it proves inept, incapable of protecting players’ financial data and regulation-averse. As such, one expects that Baines doesn’t approve of this private [...]

  • http://calvinayre.com/2011/02/13/business/scotbet-for-sale-hawaii-redefines-offshore-bc-casino/ Scotbet for sale; Hawaii redefines offshore; BC casino builder defines hypocrisy

    [...] dude… As your new facility would be regulated by the British Columbia Lottery Corporation, which exposed players’ private data via its online offering and turned a blind eye to money laundering at its (ahem) land-based [...]

  • http://calvinayre.com/2011/02/16/business/privacy-commissioner-gives-bc-lottery-corporation-spanking/ Privacy commissioner gives BC Lottery Corporation a spanking

    [...] BCLC has since identified and amended the source of the glitch that allowed PlayNow’s players to view each other’s financial info and prompted a shutdown of the site just hours after launching last July 15. All’s well that ends [...]

  • http://calvinayre.com/2011/02/09/business/ladbrokes-playtech-fancy-each-other/ Ladbrokes and Playtech fancy each other; BCLC execs fancy themselves

    [...] numbers. Of course, it’s worth noting that this survey was conducted in early 2010, prior to the gaffe-prone launch of their online offering PlayNow.com. We’ll await the next survey to learn whether that [...]

  • http://calvinayre.com/2011/07/29/business/bclc-eyes-mobile-gaming/ gaming industry: BCLC eyes mobile gaming

    [...] a horrific start to its entry into the online gambling space, the British Columbia Lottery Corporation (BCLC) is now [...]

  • http://calvinayre.com/2011/01/08/legal/bc-gaming-minister-takes-advice-calvin-ayre/ British Columbia gaming minister takes Calvin Ayre’s advice — sorta

    [...] no word on how much PlayNow.com might have received since it launched. Of course, there’s a chance that it hasn’t actually [...]

  • http://calvinayre.com/2011/09/15/business/bclc-moving-forward-with-mobile-gaming/ gaming industry: BCLC moving forward with mobile gaming

    [...] Without question, it’s the right move and the smart move. The BCLC and the Province of British Columbia, despite a shaky start into the online gambling world has recovered reasonably well. It was a case of rookie mistakes. Like the private operators in Costa Rica, the BCLC is a self regulated government organization, so they entered the online gambling market like a deer in headlights. [...]